Home / Work / TradeSumo

Built solo

TradeSumo

My first product: a marketplace for trading second-hand goods that I co-founded in 2014. It's where I fell in love with building products.

  • When January 2014 to August 2016
  • Role Co-founder: everything outside engineering
  • Where Sydney and Florida
2014The idea, at a Startup Weekend in Florida
Apr 2014Shown at One Spark as SwitchTick
2015Renamed TradeSumo and incorporated
Dec 2015Public beta in Sydney, Jacksonville and Tampa Bay
Aug 2016Shut down: no product-market fit

The product in action

A recording of the real product from December 2015: browsing what's up for trade, building an offer on the Trading Table, and sending it.

The Trading Table

Most marketplaces handled one reply to one listing at a time. The core of TradeSumo was a split screen: your inventory on one side, the other person's on the other, and a table in the middle where an offer was put together, mixing several items and cash. The idea came from trade windows in games such as World of Warcraft and RuneScape, which make multi-item trades feel simple.

The original Trading Table: give $200, a Mont Blanc pen and a PS3; get a modded cymbal and a drum kit
The real Trading Table, 2015: $200, a pen and a PS3 for a modded cymbal and a drum kit.
Explore: trade listings with an Initiate Trade button on hover
Explore: hover any listing to start a trade.
Sending a trade with an optional message and suggestions for what to write
Sending it, with prompts to say why you want the trade.

Either side could change the offer and send it back as many times as they liked. Once both accepted, free messaging opened up so they could arrange the pickup, any cash went through escrow, and both were asked to rate each other.

Trade Messages after a completed trade, with the two traders arranging the pickup
After acceptance: Trade Messages for arranging the meet-up, from the 2015 business plan.

It started as SwitchTick

We first launched as SwitchTick, at One Spark 2014 in Jacksonville, a crowdfunding festival where creators set up stands for the public. We ran ours with free candy and free stuff, and TechFaster covered us in its One Spark preview. We later renamed it TradeSumo: "Tick" was hard to say, and too easy to mishear.

Ivan Teong at the SwitchTick stand at One Spark 2014, under a sign offering free candy and free stuff
Our stand at One Spark 2014.
TechFaster article: SwitchTick puts a better spin on an old idea, One Spark preview, April 2014
TechFaster's One Spark preview, April 2014.

Solving the cold start

Every two-sided marketplace has a chicken-and-egg problem. A bartering one has it twice over: you need someone who wants exactly what you have, and has exactly what you want.

Community before product

I started trading groups on Facebook across our cities before we wrote any code: about 1,000 members before launch and more than 2,000 by the alpha. They gave us traders to bring into the product, and real trades to learn from.

Supply on day one

I seeded the first listings myself, so the first real users found an active marketplace, not an empty one. It was a bridge, phased out as real supply grew.

Learning who traded

About 60% of traders were men. Of those, roughly 70% were tradies swapping cars, bikes, trailers, tools and electronics, and 30% were students in years 11 and 12 swapping phones, consoles and computers.

Why trade at all

The value of an item is subjective. A surfboard worth $300 to its owner might be worth $600 to someone who badly wants one. Trading lets two people capture that gap with little or no cash changing hands.

Listing sites

Gumtree, Craigslist and Facebook: post an item and wait for a reply. No multi-item trades, and little had changed in a decade.

Points instead of cash

Listia and others used their own currency, which lacks the liquidity of money and loses value as platforms print more of it.

Swap only

TradeYa and others allowed swaps but no cash. Our groups showed people wanted all three: sell, swap, and swap plus cash.

TradeSumo supported all three through the Trading Table, with city communities, escrow for trust and ratings after every trade. The business model was a 5% fee on cash trades that went through escrow.

A $100 cash trade through escrow: $95 to the trader, $2.75 to TradeSumo and $2.25 to PromisePay
Where the money went on a $100 cash trade, from the business plan.

What I owned

I co-founded TradeSumo with two engineers in Florida, Daniel Sudhindaran and Rick Douglas. My remit was everything outside engineering, and there was no line between product, marketing, community and operations.

ProductWhat to build, in what order, and why, plus the core flows and design direction.
Community and supplyThe Facebook groups, and the first listings.
PitchingThird place and USD$500 at the Inventure Prize at the University of Florida.
Shipped for under AUD$1,000All the coding, design and marketing done by us, across Sydney and US time zones.

What didn't work

TradeSumo didn't reach product-market fit, and we shut it down in August 2016. Looking back, these are the four calls I would make differently.

Lesson
We didn't go mobile-first

Trading happens on a phone: you spot something you no longer need and list it. Our web app worked on phones but wasn't designed for them. Carousell, which committed to mobile only, showed the difference.

Lesson
We went too broad, too fast

Our groups told us cars, bikes and electronics were the most active categories. We launched across every category instead, and ended up with a thin marketplace where supply and demand rarely met. A deep market in one category beats a shallow one in ten.

Lesson
The first move was too big

You could only message someone by sending a formal trade. For cars and electronics, people want to ask questions and see more photos first. A simple "ask a question" would have lowered the bar.

Lesson
We left money for later

Without a revenue model in the product, we had no feedback on which trades created real value. Even a small fee forces you to learn who your valuable users are.

What I took from it

Ivan Teong at the Startup Weekend where TradeSumo began

TradeSumo is why I build products. It taught me how a marketplace starts from nothing, and that density matters more than breadth. It also showed me I wanted to be closer to customers and the market than to infrastructure, which is what took me into product management.

In 2026 I rebuilt the experience from the original recordings and business plan, so it can be tried again. The traders and listings in the reconstruction are invented.

Try the reconstruction

The Trading Table in the 2026 reconstruction
The 2026 reconstruction of the Trading Table.
Explore in the 2026 reconstruction
Explore, rebuilt.